Hamas’ Choice: Disarm or Be Destroyed

September 30, 2025

STAY INFORMED – TALKING POINTS – ACTIONS TO CONSIDER – STORIES MAKING NEWS

America’s Plan, Hamas’ Choice and the World’s Response

The war in Gaza has entered a pivotal moment. For decades, American and Israeli peace efforts have been met with rejection and violence. A new U.S. proposal now puts an ultimatum on the table: will Hamas accept reform and coexistence – or continue the war it started?

20-Point Peace Plan: Hamas Must Choose Peace or Terror

President Trump presented a plan to end the Gaza war at a joint news conference with Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu at the White House. The plan includes:

• Immediate end to hostilities once all parties accept the agreement.
• Return of all living and deceased Israeli hostages within 72 hours, in exchange for hundreds of Palestinian terrorists serving life sentences and 1,700 Palestinians arrested since Oct. 7.
• Disarmament of Hamas to create a terror-free zone, with amnesty for members who renounce violence or choose safe passage.
• Arab-led security force to replace Israeli troops and stabilize Gaza.
• Transitional civilian government to administer Gaza until Palestinian Authority reforms are complete; Hamas will have no role.
• U.S.-led peace dialogue to advance Palestinian statehood once PA reforms are achieved.
• Reconstruction and reconciliation, combining economic development with educational reform and initiatives to counter extremism and promote coexistence.

The plan now depends on the reaction of Hamas. The Iran-backed terror group would be required to end its rule of Gaza, relinquish its weapons and agree to peace with Israel. Only hours before the White House meeting, Hamas launched two rockets at Israel. They fell short, landing in Gaza.

The Palestinian Center for Policy and Survey Research revealed in May that 77% of Palestinians opposed Hamas disarmament as a condition for ending the war and most doubted that it would end the war. The same poll also showed declining support for Hamas and the Oct. 7 attacks, though still remaining high.

Leaders around the world, including Arab nations, European countries and the Palestinian Authority welcomed the proposals. The foreign ministers of Saudi Arabia, Jordan, the UAE, Indonesia, Pakistan, Turkey, Qatar and Egypt supported the plan: “We welcome President Trump’s leadership and his sincere efforts to end the war in Gaza.”

If Hamas does not comply, President Trump asserted that “Israel would have my full backing to finish the job of destroying the threat of Hamas.” The terror group is reviewing the proposal – President Trump’s stated deadline for a response is Oct. 3. Iran-backed Palestinian Islamic Jihad – which holds at least one Israeli hostage – condemned the plan.

The PA, Israel and Qatar: Peace Partners?

The Palestinian Authority also must accept significant reforms rejected for decades, including an end to incitement in schools, media and mosques it controls. The UN runs most Palestinian schools. A recent report revealed how UNRWA allowed Hamas chiefs to control its education system in Gaza and Lebanon. The PA accepted Trump’s proposal.

If the plan is approved but the Israeli government does not fully implement all elements, it will face international pressure. Netanyahu declared his opposition to a Palestinian state at the UN the week before. After the Oct. 7 atrocities, a majority of Israelis opposed Palestinian statehood in the immediate future. Netanyahu’s hardline allies are likely to resist any steps that could advance Palestinian statehood, even if the plan does not require Israel to accept it immediately.

Qatar continues to play a strategic role. The country hosts Hamas leaders and acts as an intermediary for Israel in negotiations. The Israeli Air Force recently targeted a Hamas meeting in Qatar that also killed a national security officer. In a call from the White House, Netanyahu expressed regret for the loss of life, but stressed that Israel’s target was Hamas terrorists.

The small country wields enormous influence. Qatar controls Al-Jazeera media channels, contributes billions to American universities and is leading the fight to ban Israeli teams from European soccer competitions. Seven Arab countries, including Saudi Arabia, cut ties with Qatar in 2017 because of its support for terrorism and demanded Qatar shut down Al-Jazeera. The network has banned any criticism of Hamas during the Gaza war.

Historical Rejections of Peace: ‘No negotiations’

Israelis have tried for decades to achieve a two-state solution. Palestinian and Arab leaders have consistently rejected co-existence. Arab countries launched wars of annihilation against the Jewish state in 1948, 1967 and 1973. Israel captured the West Bank from Jordan, Gaza from Egypt and the Golan from Syria in 1967’s Six-Day War. Israel offered to return the land for peace, but the Arab League responded with the “Three No’s” – No peace, no recognition and no negotiations.

Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas – serving the 20th-year of his 4-year term – asserted again at the UN that the Palestinians will hold elections within a year. His speech equated Israeli hostages with imprisoned Palestinian terrorists, wore a pin symbolizing the destruction of Israel – and has still not condemned the Oct. 7 attacks in Arabic to Palestinians.

If elections were held now, it is estimated that about two-thirds of Palestinians – in the West Bank and Gaza – would vote for Hamas in parliamentary elections. According to a 2025 survey, only 33% of Palestinians support negotiations with Israel. Also, 41% support “armed struggle” – terrorism, including 50% who think the Oct. 7 attacks were a good decision.

Recognizing Palestine: ‘Oct. 7 benefited Palestinians’

France recently led a group of nations, including Australia, Canada and the UK, recognizing Palestine as a state at the annual UN General Assembly. Of the 193 UN member states, 156 have recognized the State of Palestine since 1988. Many Israelis and Jews see this as a reward for Palestinians after Oct. 7. Franco-Israelis slammed French President Macron for “encouraging more bloodshed.”

Macron’s initiative ignored core obstacles to peace, including the Palestinian rejection of the “right of return” that would end Israel’s existence as a Jewish state. For many anti-Israel activists, recognition of Palestine does not mean reconciliation – it simply advances Israel’s elimination.

A Qatar-based Hamas leader recently admitted that Gazans are paying “a high price” in the war – but that Oct. 7 created “a golden moment” benefitting Palestinians. He falsely claimed that the Israeli hostages are being treated according to “Islamic principles.” A senior Palestinian Authority leader declared that the recognition was “the result of more than a century of resistance.”

1. Trump’s peace plan tests Hamas’ will to disarm and accept peace: The new proposal to end the Gaza war puts the burden where it belongs: on Hamas. The plan promotes security, economic development and even amnesty for Hamas members who choose co-existence. But peace only can begin if Iran-backed Hamas terrorists surrender their weapons and abandon terror. If Hamas refuses again, world leaders must clearly recognize who stands in the way of ending the war.
2. The Abraham Accords offer a vision for regional peace: Bahrain, Morocco and the UAE normalized relations with Israel in 2020 – ending years of animosity and reshaping Arab-Israeli relations. They are helping to reform education, foster cultural exchange and promote prosperity. President Trump is committed to expanding these agreements to include more nations. The Accords prove that peace and cooperation are possible when leaders reject hatred and embrace partnership.
3. Palestinian leaders must end incitement in schools, media and mosques: Peace is impossible while Palestinian Authority leaders glorify violence and poison the next generation. Schools and summer camps are named after terrorists, children’s shows celebrate killers and terrorists are paid for murdering Israelis. Instead of teaching hatred of Jews and Christians, Palestinian education must promote co-existence. True reform starts in the classroom, on TV and in worship.
4. Gaza shows why a Palestinian state cannot be built on terror: For 20 years, Gaza has effectively been a Palestinian state. Israel uprooted Jewish families in 2005 to give the Palestinians an opportunity for self-rule. Instead of building prosperity, Hamas turned Gaza into a launchpad for terror. Rockets, tunnels and the Oct. 7 massacre prove why Israelis are cautious about handing over more land in the hope of peace.
5. Premature Palestinian recognition rewards terror, not peace: Recognizing a Palestinian state now sends exactly the wrong message. Hamas calls Oct. 7 a “golden moment” despite the thousands of Palestinians killed and the Palestinian Authority treats international gains as victories for “resistance.” Rewarding rejectionism only fuels more violence, emboldening extremists – against Israel and countries around the world. Lasting peace cannot be built on the back of mass murder.
6. Permanent UN bias condemns Israel – and promotes Hamas: Hamas celebrated when dozens of countries walked out during the Israeli prime minister’s UN speech. The UN’s automatic majority – led by the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, authoritarian regimes and a few European enablers – falsely condemns Israel every year while shielding real human rights abusers, including China, Iran and North Korea. This hypocrisy rewards terrorists and undermines the UN’s credibility.

Contact your U.S. Representative and Senators to promote real peace and hold Palestinian leaders accountable. Here are four priorities to raise:

• Hold Palestinian leaders accountable: Peace requires more than promises. Hamas must disarm and the Palestinian Authority must end incitement and corruption. Ask your politicians to condition U.S. aid and diplomacy on genuine reforms – not empty words.
• Confront Qatar’s two-faced agenda: Qatar pours billions into American universities to buy influence, controls the Al-Jazeera network that spreads propaganda and shelters Hamas leaders. Tell your lawmakers to investigate Qatari funding, restrict U.S. support until it stops enabling terror and hold Al-Jazeera accountable for promoting extremism.
• Promote the Abraham Accords: Bahrain, Morocco and the UAE prove peace and prosperity are possible when nations normalize relations with Israel. Encourage your representatives to support legislation and funding that expands the Abraham Accords to more countries.
• Expose UN hypocrisy: Biased resolutions against Israel do not advance peace and undermine the credibility of international organizations. Tell your members of Congress to support America’s alliance with Israel at the UN against bias that harms both countries.

Stories Impacting American Jews

• Far-left terrorism rises in the U.S. – outnumbers far-right attacks for first time in 30 years
• More university students – 33% to 29% – think Palestine is a better U.S. ally than Israel
• Man who hated Jews charged with arson for setting fire to Florida Jewish school
• Anti-Israel arsonist sentenced to 19 years for bombing police car in Berkeley, CA, vows to continue activism from prison
• South Park TV show taps into common anti-Jewish trope of blaming Jews, Israel for “making life for Jews miserable.”
• Jerusalem Post‘s annual lists: 50 Most Influential Jews, 25 Young Visionaries, 10 Pro-Israel Christians

Stories Impacting the U.S. and Israel

• Anti-Israel Tunisian activist leaves Gaza-bound flotilla over inclusion of LGBTQ+ activists, blames “Zionist lobby.”
• NYC Mayor Adams thanks Israeli prime minister for “defending the Western world and our way of life.”
• UN Security Council held meeting on Rosh Hashanah, UN social media accounts again did not recognize Jewish holiday
• EU reimposes sanctions on Iran for its nuclear weapons program
• Iran-backed Houthi terrorists in Yemen continue to fire missiles at Israel, hit another cargo ship with rocket
• IDF soldier killed in terror attack in West Bank
• Syria’s leader – who served in Al-Qaeda for 20 years – declares his “commitment to dialogue” with Israel, but he opposes normalization and continues to attack Syrian minorities

Stories from Around the World

• France: “Dirty Jew, I’m going to kill you”: Man injured in Paris attack
• Europe: Jews, Israelis face increasing death threats, business bans across Europe
• Germany: Pizzeria bans all Israelis until they “open their eyes” to Gaza

Click Below to Access Additional Focus Project Resources:

Stay Informed | Speak Up | Take Action

Want to Read More of Our Talking Points? Did you miss a recent edition of The Focus Project? No need to search your inbox. Our most recently published editions are available on our website.

This content is developed by The Focus Project in partnership with MERCAZ USA. The Focus Project distributes weekly news and talking points on timely issues concerning Israel and the Jewish people, including antisemitism, anti-Zionism and the delegitimization of Israel. It represents a consensus view across a spectrum of major American Jewish organizations. MERCAZ USA recognizes and respects the diversity of views on these issues among its readers and the community at large.

The Focus Project develops and distributes news, background, history and weekly talking points on timely issues to inform individuals and organizations about issues affecting the American Jewish community and Israel, and help readers speak with more consistency and clarity. The editions also provide potential responses for addressing incidents of antisemitism and anti-Zionism. With input from a spectrum of major American Jewish organizations, we focus on that which unites us, rising above political and individual agendas.

Recognizing that hatred of Jews comes in many forms and directions, we strive to address all sources as they arise, and educate our growing audience on topics ranging from inter-religious relations to relevant international developments. From week to week, we may focus on issues arising from the political left, university campuses, from the political right and from institutions, government, and corporations. We don’t try to address all issues in each edition. We hope you will find this information useful in your writing and/or speaking. We are always open to your feedback: info@focus-project.org.

Copyright © 2025 The Focus Project, All rights reserved.